While the Up-C structure can unlock significant value, it’s not without complexity. It requires sophisticated planning, strong governance, and ongoing compliance. Executives should understand the following risks and operational challenges before moving forward:
Structural complexity and upfront planning
An Up-C transaction involves multiple entities, exchange rights, and contractual agreements such as tax receivable agreements (TRAs). Designing these elements requires careful coordination among tax, legal and accounting teams. Without thorough planning, the structure can become cumbersome and costly.
Ongoing compliance obligations
After the IPO, the Up-C structure demands continuous attention. Each exchange of partnership units for PubCo shares triggers tax basis adjustments, TRA calculations, and financial reporting updates. Companies must maintain robust processes to track these events accurately and comply with partnership tax rules.
Financial reporting challenges
Accounting for noncontrolling interests, deferred tax assets, and TRA liabilities adds complexity to financial statements. Avoiding unnecessary impact on earnings is key. Missteps in reporting can lead to restatements or investor concerns.
Publicly traded partnership (PTP) rules
The operating partnership must avoid classification as a publicly traded partnership taxed as a corporation. This requires careful management of ownership and trading restrictions to preserve flow-through status.
Cash flow considerations for TRA payments
TRA obligations can be substantial. While they are tied to actual tax savings, they represent real cash outflows for PubCo. Companies must model these payments and ensure they have sufficient liquidity to meet obligations without straining operations.
Market perception and investor education
Up-C structures are not new, but they remain less common than traditional IPOs, and investors may need education on how the structure works and why it benefits both the company and legacy owners. Clear communication is essential to avoid confusion or skepticism.
Tax law changes and modeling uncertainty
The value of basis step-ups and TRA payments depends on future tax rates and regulations. Legislative changes could reduce expected benefits, so companies should model multiple scenarios and understand potential downside risks.