Growth and maturity depend on strong leadership, governance and communication.
Key takeaways
Proactive planning helps employee‑owners sustain value and manage complexity.
Regular assessments can reveal growth barriers and strategic opportunities.
The employee benefits landscape is rapidly evolving, and organizations are increasingly recognizing the value of employee stock ownership plans (ESOPs) for long-term growth and success. Whether a company is researching ESOPs as an option, or is at an early, middle or well-established ESOP stage, it is important to understand that navigating people, culture and financial considerations is critical to optimizing cash flows and building a competitive advantage.
According to reports, ESOP-owned businesses post stronger growth numbers than their peers and tend to see lower turnover rates. For example, recent Aspen Institute data shows that employee ownership strategies, combined with a supportive culture, can reduce voluntary turnover from 13% per year to about 2%. To sustain this growth and continuity potential, it is important to fully develop ESOP strategies with strong financial literacy, effective communications and stakeholder management.
To help companies understand the stages of ESOP maturity for long-term growth and success, RSM US Partners Anne Bushman and Justin Stallard and Director Jo-Ann Balmer discussed practical guidelines and strategies to optimize cash flows, financial capabilities and governance in RSM’s latest webinar Own it: Leading your ESOP through the stages of maturity. Below, we take a look at their key insights for developing successful ESOP strategies, including strategic considerations and regulatory guidelines to establish a strong ownership culture across the organization.
It’s always the chicken or egg conversation, whether a strong culture enables a successful ESOP or an ESOP transforms the culture later. However, when implemented thoughtfully, an ESOP can significantly enhance organizational culture.
Anne Bushman, Partner, RSM US LLP
Successful ESOP strategies and processes
Whether it is designed to advance your organization’s culture or create an attractive retirement benefit for employees, an ESOP fundamentally enables employees to act, function and be rewarded like owners in the business. In addition, private equity firms are increasingly adopting broad-based ownership structures, because engaged, owner-minded employees help drive stronger performance. Even when companies offer up to 10% ownership, resulting gains in productivity, commitment and company value often outweigh the cost at exit. This growing trend highlights broader recognition that employee ownership supports long-term success and higher valuations.
Organizational change management (OCM) is a critical component necessary for effective planning and execution across multiple stages of ESOP maturity. Since establishing an ESOP is a major strategic change initiative, the primary goal should be to drive workforce acceptance of a new operating model, leading to better utilization and adoption. OCM also helps strengthen operational resilience by supporting the shift in culture and mindset, reinforcing the difference between being an employee and transitioning to an employee-owner.
Leaders can support this transition by fully engaging with employees and actively communicating the benefits of employee ownership. Setting expectations for desired employee ownership behaviors and following through with consistent messaging throughout the adoption phase of an ESOP—at every stage of maturity—is important. This helps develop a robust ownership culture by building trust and promoting transparent engagement across the organization.
It’s extremely important that the cultural shift that happens at the beginning is built on trust and clarity. Another critical component is to improve financial literacy as the ESOP progresses. The ownership mindset is different for every person and every tier within an organization.
Jo-Ann Balmer, Director, RSM US LLP
Stages of ESOP maturity
Adopting an ESOP is not a simple switch but a process that requires thoughtful, flexible planning. The three stages in ESOP maturity with dedicated timelines are as follows:
Stage one: Early implementation
Stage one: Early implementation
Timeline: Initial adoption to three years
During the initial years, the goal is to help internal teams understand the ESOP structure, service provider roles and ongoing requirements as they build familiarity with the plan. Guidelines include:
- Operational resilience with strategic planning
- Avoid a one-size-fits-all approach by tailoring plans to the workforce demographics.
- Integrate the ESOP into the broader total rewards and retirement strategy, particularly alongside existing plans, such as 401(k)s, with messaging tailored to more tenured employees versus younger employees.
- Communicate any changes within the new compliance, governance and reporting processes.
- Cultural stewardship and employee engagement
- Compare the ESOP with other components of the total rewards package to help employees better understand its value.
- Build financial literacy by sharing annual statements that outline each employee’s number of shares, share values and vesting percentage.
- Establish ESOP committees and develop dedicated forms like FAQs to guide employees through the transition and to further establish the ownership culture.
- Compliance and governance
- Define service providers responsible for specific reporting requirements and assistance.
- Manage stakeholder expectations.
- Adopt a measured ESOP loan‑repayment strategy to maintain compliance, prevent accelerated share allocations and repurchase‑obligation pressures, and support long‑term ownership and workforce sustainability.
Stage two: Mid-life optimization
Stage two: Mid-life optimization
Timeline: Three to 10+ years
During this phase, the focus shifts to optimization as a follow-on to ESOP implementation. Guidelines include:
- Operational resilience with strategic planning
- Reassess plan design, benefit levels and cash flows as internal ESOP debt is paid down and company finances evolve.
- Increase focus on repurchase obligation planning as employee balances grow and distributions become more frequent, including evaluating frequent repurchase obligation studies.
- Integrate the ESOP into the broader compensation and benefits strategy as part of the total rewards package.
- Clearly address how the ESOP relates to each employee’s role and stage.
- Cultural stewardship and employee engagement
- Drive consistent communication targeting ongoing engagement, onboarding integration and leadership reinforcement.
- Implement targeted plan amendments, such as adjusting eligibility ages or entry dates to better support hiring and strengthen the ownership culture.
- Focus on collective growth and optimization to address change fatigue.
- Support leadership transitions and reinforce role modeling of ownership behaviors.
- Compliance and governance
- With improved cash availability, consider adding segregation to avoid building up former employees within the ESOP plan.
A mature, roughly 10–12-year-old ESOP can operate with confidence once the company is beyond the initial learning curve, supported by a strong culture and engaged employees who share in valuation gains. More advanced ESOPs conduct regular valuation and repurchase obligation studies and may use pre-evaluations to manage stakeholder expectations and avoid surprises.
At this stage, new financial pressures begin to emerge, including repurchase obligations, segregation and warrants, which can create significant cash outflows. In addition, as share values escalate, companies must address the growing cost of capital tied to former owners, prompting more strategic long-term financial planning.
Stage three: Long-term stewardship
Stage three: Long-term stewardship
Timeline: 10 to 12+ years
At this level, ESOP conversations shift toward sustainability, growth and strategic decision making. Guidelines include:
- Operational resilience with strategic planning
- In addition to repurchase obligation studies, focus on sustainability analysis and different scenario planning.
- Reassess the plan, including the segregation and warrant.
- Adapt to new cash flows, while staying in a growth mindset.
- Cultural stewardship and employee engagement
- Evolve financial and business literacy.
- Build cultural stewards and empowered champions.
- Reinforce ownership mindset to bridge the gap between mature employees and new hires.
- Strengthen adaptability with reduced change fatigue.
- Compliance and governance
- Evaluate diversification strategies as they are statutorily required to be offered to employees aged 55 and older who have been in the plan for 10 years.
- Navigate merger and acquisition possibilities and amendments.
In mature ESOP-owned companies, valuation transparency can sometimes hinder M&A decision making. Leaders may hesitate to pursue acquisitions that appear dilutive based on EBITDA multiples, even when the transaction could create long-term value through synergies and growth. Rather than focusing solely on headline multiples, ESOP-owned businesses should assess whether an acquisition can enhance overall enterprise value and earnings over time, requiring a more strategic and nuanced approach to M&A decisions as the ESOP matures.
Stages of ESOP maturity
Adopting an ESOP is not a simple switch but a process that requires thoughtful, flexible planning. The three stages in ESOP maturity with dedicated timelines are as follows:
Stage one: Early implementation
Timeline: Initial adoption to three years
During the initial years, the goal is to help internal teams understand the ESOP structure, service provider roles and ongoing requirements as they build familiarity with the plan. Guidelines include:
- Operational resilience with strategic planning
- Avoid a one-size-fits-all approach by tailoring plans to the workforce demographics.
- Integrate the ESOP into the broader total rewards and retirement strategy, particularly alongside existing plans, such as 401(k)s, with messaging tailored to more tenured employees versus younger employees.
- Communicate any changes within the new compliance, governance and reporting processes.
- Cultural stewardship and employee engagement
- Compare the ESOP with other components of the total rewards package to help employees better understand its value.
- Build financial literacy by sharing annual statements that outline each employee’s number of shares, share values and vesting percentage.
- Establish ESOP committees and develop dedicated forms like FAQs to guide employees through the transition and to further establish the ownership culture.
- Compliance and governance
- Define service providers responsible for specific reporting requirements and assistance.
- Manage stakeholder expectations.
- Adopt a measured ESOP loan‑repayment strategy to maintain compliance, prevent accelerated share allocations and repurchase‑obligation pressures, and support long‑term ownership and workforce sustainability.
Stage two: Mid-life optimization
Timeline: Three to 10+ years
During this phase, the focus shifts to optimization as a follow-on to ESOP implementation. Guidelines include:
- Operational resilience with strategic planning
- Reassess plan design, benefit levels and cash flows as internal ESOP debt is paid down and company finances evolve.
- Increase focus on repurchase obligation planning as employee balances grow and distributions become more frequent, including evaluating frequent repurchase obligation studies.
- Integrate the ESOP into the broader compensation and benefits strategy as part of the total rewards package.
- Clearly address how the ESOP relates to each employee’s role and stage.
- Cultural stewardship and employee engagement
- Drive consistent communication targeting ongoing engagement, onboarding integration and leadership reinforcement.
- Implement targeted plan amendments, such as adjusting eligibility ages or entry dates to better support hiring and strengthen the ownership culture.
- Focus on collective growth and optimization to address change fatigue.
- Support leadership transitions and reinforce role modeling of ownership behaviors.
- Compliance and governance
- With improved cash availability, consider adding segregation to avoid building up former employees within the ESOP plan.
A mature, roughly 10–12-year-old ESOP can operate with confidence once the company is beyond the initial learning curve, supported by a strong culture and engaged employees who share in valuation gains. More advanced ESOPs conduct regular valuation and repurchase obligation studies and may use pre-evaluations to manage stakeholder expectations and avoid surprises.
At this stage, new financial pressures begin to emerge, including repurchase obligations, segregation and warrants, which can create significant cash outflows. In addition, as share values escalate, companies must address the growing cost of capital tied to former owners, prompting more strategic long-term financial planning.
Stage three: Long-term stewardship
Timeline: 10 to 12+ years
At this level, ESOP conversations shift toward sustainability, growth and strategic decision making. Guidelines include:
- Operational resilience with strategic planning
- In addition to repurchase obligation studies, focus on sustainability analysis and different scenario planning.
- Reassess the plan, including the segregation and warrant.
- Adapt to new cash flows, while staying in a growth mindset.
- Cultural stewardship and employee engagement
- Evolve financial and business literacy.
- Build cultural stewards and empowered champions.
- Reinforce ownership mindset to bridge the gap between mature employees and new hires.
- Strengthen adaptability with reduced change fatigue.
- Compliance and governance
- Evaluate diversification strategies as they are statutorily required to be offered to employees aged 55 and older who have been in the plan for 10 years.
- Navigate merger and acquisition possibilities and amendments.
In mature ESOP-owned companies, valuation transparency can sometimes hinder M&A decision making. Leaders may hesitate to pursue acquisitions that appear dilutive based on EBITDA multiples, even when the transaction could create long-term value through synergies and growth. Rather than focusing solely on headline multiples, ESOP-owned businesses should assess whether an acquisition can enhance overall enterprise value and earnings over time, requiring a more strategic and nuanced approach to M&A decisions as the ESOP matures.
An effective and sustainable ESOP is about how employees feel the ownership structure, the accountability. When you get the entire organization pulling on the rope, acting like owners going the extra mile, spending the extra 15 minutes taking care of a customer really elevates the game and increases momentum going forward.
Justin Stallard, Partner, RSM US LLP
Frequently asked questions
What are the key benefits of a well-executed ESOP?
Fostering an ownership mindset, maintaining a highly engaged workforce and supporting low turnover are key outcomes of a well-executed ESOP strategy.
Why is financial literacy important in an ESOP?
Financial education helps employees understand how the ESOP works and what their ownership means, reinforcing trust and long-term engagement.
The takeaway
With the ongoing evolution of ESOPs, middle market businesses are increasingly recognizing their potential to drive long-term value. Regardless of where your company sits in the ESOP lifecycle, proactive planning and forward-looking vision are essential, considering trends in employee departures, diversification requests and cash flow needs. Building in a commitment to strengthening financial literacy and ownership mindset values across the organization is critical to successfully designing, implementing and sustaining an ESOP.
Amid evolving economic policies and regulatory updates, your company should reassess your ESOP maturity stage to strengthen cash flows and optimize total rewards. While you may have a good idea of how to navigate these complexities, additional support may be necessary to help drive informed decision making, avoid surprises and support long-term ESOP sustainability.
Ready to get started? RSM’s experienced advisors understand the ESOP landscape and can help your organization evaluate ESOP readiness, plan for ESOP implementation, adjust strategies proactively and integrate new developments into long-term ESOP planning. Contact our team to learn how RSM can help transform your ESOP processes and growth.
RSM contributors
Related insights
